palo alto
syndicate
Check eligibility
All articlesValues investing

Tokenisation and Digital Securities: Hype vs Reality for Startup Equity

Tokenisation promises to make startup equity more accessible and liquid. Here is what tokenised securities are, the regulatory landscape across regions, and the gap between hype and reality.

Palo Alto Syndicate4 min read

Key points

  1. Tokenised securities represent traditional securities on blockchains.
  2. Benefits include fractional ownership and faster settlement.
  3. Securities laws still apply, and liquidity is often limited.
  4. Regulators across regions are exploring frameworks through pilots.

Tokenisation means representing ownership of an asset, such as shares, as digital tokens on a blockchain. Proponents argue that tokenised securities could make startup investing more accessible, transparent and liquid. Critics point to regulatory uncertainty, limited liquidity and past failures. The reality lies somewhere in between.

What are tokenised securities?

Tokenised securities are digital representations of traditional securities, such as shares or bonds, recorded on a blockchain. They are generally subject to the same securities laws as traditional securities.

Potential benefits

  • Fractional ownership: smaller minimum investments.
  • Faster settlement: reduced time and cost to transfer ownership.
  • Programmability: automated compliance and corporate actions.
  • Transparency: clearer records of ownership.
  • Liquidity: potential secondary trading on regulated platforms.

Challenges

  • Regulation: securities laws apply, and frameworks are still developing.
  • Liquidity: many tokenised markets have limited trading.
  • Technology risk: smart contract errors and cybersecurity.
  • Investor protection: past token offerings involved fraud and losses.
  • Integration: connecting blockchain systems with traditional infrastructure.

Lessons from initial coin offerings

The initial coin offering boom of 2017 and 2018 saw many projects raise money through tokens without proper disclosure or regulation, and many failed or were fraudulent. Regulators responded by applying securities laws to tokens that function as securities.

Regulatory landscape by region

Australia. ASIC has issued guidance on digital assets, and regulators have explored tokenisation through projects such as the Reserve Bank’s research on wholesale digital money and asset tokenisation. Tokenised securities must comply with existing securities and financial services laws.

United States. The SEC applies securities laws to tokens that are securities. Regulatory approaches to digital assets have shifted over time, and tokenised securities must comply with registration or exemption requirements.

Europe. The EU’s DLT Pilot Regime allows market infrastructures to experiment with trading and settling tokenised securities. The Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) covers crypto-assets that are not securities.

Asia. Singapore’s Project Guardian, led by the Monetary Authority of Singapore, explores asset tokenisation with financial institutions. Other markets are developing frameworks.

What this means for founders

  • Tokenisation does not avoid securities laws.
  • Practical benefits for most startups remain limited today.
  • Founders should be cautious about tokenised offers without strong legal advice.

What this means for investors

  • Tokenised securities carry the same risks as traditional startup investments, plus technology risks.
  • Liquidity is not guaranteed.
  • Regulatory protections vary.

A practical example

A hypothetical European real estate technology company issued tokenised shares through a regulated platform participating in an EU pilot regime. Investors could buy small fractions and trade them on the platform. Trading volume was modest, and the company found that legal and compliance costs were similar to a traditional offering. The project demonstrated the potential of tokenisation but also its current limitations.

Questions to ask about a tokenised offer

Investors considering tokenised securities should ask:

  • Is the offer made under a recognised securities law framework or exemption?
  • Who holds custody of the tokens, and how are they protected?
  • Where can the tokens be traded, and is the trading venue regulated?
  • What rights do token holders have compared with ordinary shareholders?
  • What happens to the tokens if the platform fails?

Clear answers are essential. If an offer seems to promise high returns with little disclosure, investors should be cautious.

Where tokenisation may help first

Early practical uses of tokenisation are more likely to appear in areas such as fund units, private credit and real-world assets, where fractional ownership and faster settlement can reduce costs. For startup equity, the benefits may come later, once regulatory frameworks and trading venues mature.

What founders should consider

Founders exploring tokenisation should weigh the potential benefits against costs, regulatory complexity and investor familiarity. Most venture investors still prefer traditional share structures, and a tokenised cap table could complicate future rounds. For now, tokenisation is best viewed as an emerging option rather than a replacement for traditional fundraising.

The long-term view

Over time, tokenisation could improve the efficiency of private markets by making ownership records more transparent and transfers faster. Regulators’ pilot programmes suggest growing interest. Founders and investors should follow developments, but approach current offers with caution and strong legal advice.

A balanced view

Tokenisation is neither a fad nor a revolution that will transform startup investing overnight. It is a technology that may gradually improve how ownership is recorded and transferred, provided legal frameworks, market infrastructure and investor protections develop alongside it. Founders and investors should stay curious but cautious.

Frequently asked questions

Yes, if issued in compliance with securities laws. They are generally treated as securities.

Do tokenised shares guarantee liquidity?

No. Liquidity depends on market demand and regulated trading venues.

Can startups raise money through tokens?

They can, but offers must comply with securities laws, and the benefits for most startups remain limited.

Is tokenisation the future of startup investing?

It may play a growing role, but significant regulatory and market development is needed.

General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.

A new article every Monday.

Market news, investor education, founder guides, values investing and the rules, in plain English. Follow by RSS, or join the waitlist to hear when seats open.