palo alto
syndicate
Check eligibility
All articlesValues investing

Checking impact claims: how values-led investors avoid greenwashing

Saying a company does good is easy. Showing it is harder. Recent court penalties show the regulator takes misleading sustainability claims seriously. Here is how to test the claims a startup makes.

Palo Alto Syndicate3 min read

Key points

  1. ASIC has won civil penalties against fund managers over misleading sustainability claims, including a record $12.9 million against Vanguard.
  2. Impact claims deserve the same evidence as financial claims.
  3. Good claims are specific, measured, current and honest about trade-offs.
  4. Founders who make claims they can prove build more trust with investors.

Values investing rests on a promise: that your money backs something you believe in. That promise is only as good as the claims behind it.

Greenwashing, or impact-washing, is when a company or product claims to be more sustainable, ethical or beneficial than it really is. It misleads investors, and it undermines the companies that are doing the real work.

The regulator is watching

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has made misleading sustainability claims an enforcement priority. In its first three greenwashing civil penalty cases, the Federal Court ordered:

  • Vanguard Investments Australia to pay $12.9 million, a record at the time, over claims that a bond fund screened out certain industries when many of its holdings were not screened.
  • Mercer Superannuation to pay $11.3 million over claims about “sustainable” investment options that held companies in industries members were told were excluded.
  • Active Super to pay $10.5 million over claims that it excluded certain investments that it in fact held.

These were large, regulated fund managers. Startups are held to the same basic rule: don’t mislead.

An impact claim is a factual claim. It needs the same evidence as a revenue figure.

Five questions to test any claim

1. Is it specific? “Better for the planet” tells you nothing. “Cuts water use per tonne by a measured amount compared with the current method” tells you something you can check.

2. Is it measured? Ask what is measured, how, by whom and how often. A claim based on a single pilot or a model is a hypothesis, not a result.

3. Is it current? Impact claims age. A figure from a two-year-old pilot may not describe the business today.

4. Is it the whole picture? Most products involve trade-offs. A credible company tells you about them, for example the emissions from manufacturing as well as the savings in use.

5. Is it tied to the business? The strongest impact is built into what a company sells. When the impact grows as the business grows, the incentives line up. When impact is a side project, it is the first thing cut when money is tight.

For founders

If your company’s purpose is part of your pitch, treat your impact claims like your financial ones. Keep the evidence. Use plain, specific words. Say what you don’t yet know. Investors who care about impact will ask, and the ones worth having will respect a straight answer more than a big claim.

How we approach it

At Palo Alto Syndicate, our value of plain truth applies to impact as much as risk. If a deal page describes a company’s purpose, it describes what the company does, not what it hopes to achieve. Claims are checked as part of the homework, and investors decide for themselves.


Sources and further reading

  • ASIC, ASIC’s Vanguard greenwashing action results in record $12.9 million penalty, media release 24-213MR. asic.gov.au
  • Gadens, ASIC succeeds in its third civil penalty prosecution for greenwashing. gadens.com
  • Gilbert + Tobin, Largest greenwashing penalty so far of $12.9m imposed on Vanguard. gtlaw.com.au
The numbersGreenwashing penalties won by ASICCivil penalties ordered by the Federal Court in ASIC’s first three greenwashing proceedings.

Source: ASIC and Gadens

General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.

A new article every Monday.

Market news, investor education, founder guides, values investing and the rules, in plain English. Follow by RSS, or join the waitlist to hear when seats open.