The Option Pool Shuffle: How Pool Size Affects Your Real Valuation
The option pool shuffle is one of the most common ways founders lose value in a funding round without realising it. Here is how it works and how to negotiate the right pool size.
Key points
- The option pool shuffle reduces founders' effective valuation.
- Size the pool to a realistic hiring plan.
- Calculate effective pre-money when comparing offers.
- Count existing unallocated options before agreeing to a new pool.
Founders often focus on the headline valuation in a term sheet. But one clause can quietly reduce the real value they receive: the option pool. When investors require an option pool to be created or increased before their investment, and included in the pre-money valuation, founders bear all of the dilution. This is known as the option pool shuffle.
How the shuffle works
Imagine an investor offers $3 million at a $12 million pre-money valuation, for a post-money valuation of $15 million and 20 per cent ownership. The term sheet requires a 15 per cent post-money option pool, included in the pre-money.
- Investor: 20 per cent.
- Option pool: 15 per cent.
- Founders and existing shareholders: 65 per cent.
Without the pool requirement, founders would own 80 per cent. The pool reduces the founders’ effective pre-money valuation from $12 million to about $9.75 million, because only 65 per cent of the $15 million post-money belongs to them.
Why investors ask for this
Investors want the company to have enough options to hire key staff without further diluting the new investors. Including the pool in the pre-money ensures that existing shareholders, not new investors, bear the dilution.
How to negotiate pool size
- Build a hiring plan. Identify the roles you will hire before the next round and the equity each requires.
- Size the pool to the plan, not to an arbitrary percentage.
- Count existing unallocated options.
- Negotiate a smaller pool with the option to top up later.
- Consider post-money pools in some cases.
Comparing offers
When comparing term sheets, calculate the effective pre-money valuation:
Effective pre-money = headline pre-money − value of new options included in the pre-money
A lower headline valuation with a smaller pool can be better than a higher valuation with a large pool.
Common mistakes founders make
- Accepting arbitrary pool sizes.
- Ignoring the pool when comparing term sheets.
- Failing to track existing unallocated options.
- Creating oversized pools that remain unused.
Regional considerations
Australia. Option pool requirements are common in Australian venture deals. Founders should consider the ESS startup concession and plan pools that suit their hiring needs.
United States. The option pool shuffle is well known in the US, and founders commonly negotiate pool size using hiring plans.
Europe. Pool requirements are common. In the UK, EMI scheme limits affect how options are granted.
Asia. Pool requirements are common in Singapore and other markets.
A practical example
A hypothetical founder received a term sheet with a 20 per cent post-money pool requirement included in the pre-money. She prepared a hiring plan for the next 18 months showing a need for about 9 per cent of the company in new grants, with 3 per cent already available in the existing pool. She negotiated a top-up to a 12 per cent pool instead. The change increased the founders’ effective pre-money valuation significantly without changing the headline number.
How to build the hiring plan
A credible hiring plan lists each role the company expects to hire before its next round, the likely timing and the equity each role typically receives. Senior hires such as a head of engineering or head of sales usually receive larger grants than early individual contributors. Founders can use market data from equity benchmarking surveys, advisors and investors to estimate grant sizes. Adding up these grants, plus a buffer for unexpected hires and refresh grants, gives a defensible pool size.
Pre-money vs post-money pools
Some term sheets specify the pool as a percentage of the post-money capitalisation but include it in the pre-money valuation. Others specify a pre-money percentage. The difference affects the calculation. Founders should ask their lawyers to model the exact effect of the proposed wording.
Refreshing the pool later
Option pools often need topping up in later rounds as the company hires more people and refreshes grants for existing employees. Founders should expect this and plan for it. Agreeing a smaller pool now and topping it up later, when the company’s valuation is higher, can reduce total founder dilution.
The bigger picture
The option pool exists to help the company hire and retain great people. Founders should not try to minimise it to the point where they cannot compete for talent. The goal is a pool sized realistically for the company’s needs, negotiated with an understanding of who bears the dilution.
One question to always ask
When an investor proposes a pool size, ask them to explain how they arrived at it. A clear answer tied to hiring needs is reasonable; an arbitrary figure is negotiable.
Frequently asked questions
Why is it called the option pool shuffle?
Because the pool is “shuffled” into the pre-money valuation, shifting dilution onto existing shareholders.
What is a typical option pool size?
Pools of 10 to 15 per cent are common at seed and Series A, but the right size depends on hiring plans.
Can I refuse an option pool?
Investors usually require some pool. Founders can negotiate its size and structure.
What happens to unused options?
Unused options remain in the pool and can be granted later. Oversized pools create unnecessary dilution.
Related reading
General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.